Against Meritocracy

0
3

We have grown up with the foundational teaching that modern democracy is the very best form of government and that it should be exported to the entire world. Many of us are now coming to the realisation that the modern democratic system is instead one of the very worst systems of government ever tried, and that its ultimate expression results in the enslavement and even replacement of a country’s native population.

I have already written several articles on this theme, so feel free to have a look through my back catalogue. But it has occurred to me that there is another foundational teaching of our modern democratic societies which goes hand in hand with the democratic process, and which we have been told since birth is the very best thing ever. And that is the question of meritocracy.

At its core, meritocracy seems to be a notion that is inherently good and true. Each individual in a society has the possibility to rise to their own level of competence. The very best individuals are selected for positions of importance. Everyone is encouraged to strive to succeed, and the nation benefits as a result. Who could not accept such a wonderful proposition?

Marxists, socialists, whatever you want to call the demon loving entities that strive to destroy us, they always work on the young. New ideas that would have been unthinkable to earlier generations are programmed into the minds of young people so that they carry forward the new evil without the knowledge of what went before it. We too were once young, and we were programmed just as are the young of today.

In the time of Catholic monarchies such a thing as meritocracy was very much secondary to the contrary idea of duty and service to God and the nation through one’s standing of birth. If you were born the son of a carpenter then a carpenter you would then be. As the son of a carpenter you would not have to wonder what your calling was in life. You would not have to go out and find yourself or restart over from zero when you reached adulthood. There were no such thing as guidance counsellors because you followed in the footsteps of your father and of a guild. And with such a background you learnt from those who had generations of teaching to back them up. You learnt from the best.

This is one of the key reasons why it would not be possible to build the great cathedrals today. We lack the knowledge because it was no longer handed down. During the French revolution, the ancient guilds were closed and outlawed. It became every young man for himself.

And under meritocracy that is precisely what every young man and woman does. They are in it for themselves. Meritocracy is the path of the individual. There is no service to God, community or nation inherent in meritocracy. Even service to one’s family is almost non existent. The Boomers were the first generation to grow up with the really big push for individualism and meritocracy and we all know how that turned out. In meritocracy, everyone is out for themselves, for all they can get, to maximise their potential, to earn all of the money possible, to cash out and live big.

Except, with DEI now we don’t even have meritocracy. It has been given to those replacing us. So white men do not have meritocracy and they do not have anything that they were born into. Even those who are fortunate enough to be born into a family business, or a family farm, or a family trade, are brainwashed at school that to participate in such work would be akin to slavery, and so they must go out and start again from zero.

In a meritorious system, virtue is discouraged and vice is encouraged. The virtuous are cast aside and the devious succeed. Meritorious does not infer any moral standing. Who can claw their way to the top are the winners. It is no coincidence that secularism was adopted at the same time as widespread meritocracy. Such a new system worked well when it was populated by those men who still held to the moral teachings of more virtuous earlier generations. But once those men were gone then the system became a race to the bottom while claiming to promote the best.

I am still formulating my thinking on this topic, as it is hard to go against what we were taught from a young age was the right thing. But the more I think about it, the more I become convinced that meritocracy simply means that we get exactly what we deserved. And looking around at the moral ruin of our nations, it seems to me that we have deserved the worst.

You can find Adam Piggott at Substack, and purchase his books here.

Previous articleThe Real Estate Apocalypse
Adam Piggott
Adam Piggott writes about all things red pill and nationalist right. He examines what it means to be a man in the modern world and gives men advice beyond the typical 'how to pull chicks', (although he does that too.) He plays the guitar, smokes cigars, drinks wine and rum, rides motorbikes, is bad at cricket, and distrusts any man who has no redeeming petty vices. He does his best to be a reality check to any Millennials or progressives so unfortunate as to cross his path.